Miami is famous for its vibrant food scene, and when it comes to Italian cuisine, the city delivers with everything from rustic trattorias to modern fine-dining spots. Whether you’re searching for a romantic dinner, casual pizza, or a trendy pasta bar, Miami’s Italian restaurants cater to every taste and budget. Tourists visiting Miami often want more than just a meal—they want an experience that blends atmosphere, service, and authentic Italian flavors. This guide explores the very best Italian restaurants in Miami, with expanded details on what makes each spot special, so you can plan the perfect dining experience during your stay.
Macchialina – Best Pasta Restaurant in South Beach
- 📍 Address: 820 Alton Rd, Miami Beach
- 💲 Price Range: $$$$
- 🍝 Highlights: Handcrafted pastas, creamy polenta, six signature pastas
- 🥗 Dietary Options: Vegetarian-friendly; gluten-free pasta available on request
- 🏠 Ambience: Cozy, rustic, and intimate with a small patio
- ❤️ Best For: Foodies and couples
- 📅 Reservations: Highly recommended
- 🌐 Website: macchialina.com
Macchialina is a South Beach classic and has become a culinary landmark for Italian cuisine in Miami. Known for its rustic tavern charm and a menu centered around artisanal pasta, it’s a spot where simplicity meets flavor. The tasting menu, priced at $75, is generously portioned and lets guests explore a variety of pasta creations, from rich cacio e pepe to indulgent truffle-laced dishes. The intimate atmosphere makes it a perfect destination for couples who want to share a romantic yet unfussy dinner. It’s also popular with locals, which is always a great sign for tourists seeking authenticity.
Casa Tua – Most Romantic Italian Restaurant in Miami Beach
- 📍 Address: 1700 James Ave, Miami Beach
- 💲 Price Range: $$$$
- 🍝 Highlights: Homemade pastas, burrata, branzino, veal dishes
- 🥗 Dietary Options: Vegetarian and gluten-free pasta available
- 🏠 Ambience: Romantic villa with a beautiful courtyard
- ❤️ Best For: Special occasions, anniversaries, and date nights
- 📅 Reservations: Essential (often books weeks ahead)
- 🌐 Website: casatualife.com
Casa Tua is one of the most iconic fine-dining Italian restaurants in Miami. Set inside a Mediterranean-style villa with elegant décor and a lush courtyard, the restaurant radiates romance and exclusivity. Its menu showcases a perfect balance of tradition and refinement, with dishes like branzino al forno and veal ossobuco. The service is attentive and refined, making it ideal for anniversaries, proposals, or once-in-a-lifetime celebrations. Tourists visiting Miami often put Casa Tua on their must-try list because it’s more than a restaurant—it’s an experience of old-world elegance in the heart of South Beach.
Felice Brickell – Best Tuscan Restaurant in Miami
- 📍 Address: 1450 Brickell Ave #110, Miami
- 💲 Price Range: $$$
- 🍝 Highlights: Tuscan flavors, fettuccine Bolognese, branzino al cartoccio
- 🥗 Dietary Options: Vegetarian-friendly; gluten-free pasta available
- 🏠 Ambience: Chic and stylish, great for business dinners or dates
- ❤️ Best For: Wine lovers and professionals
- 📅 Reservations: Recommended
- 🌐 Website: felicerestaurants.com
Felice Brickell is a sophisticated Tuscan eatery that combines comfort with elegance. The restaurant is well-regarded for its authentic Tuscan recipes, particularly its hearty pasta dishes and fresh seafood specialties. A highlight for many visitors is the extensive wine list, featuring regional Italian wines that pair perfectly with the dishes. Felice offers an upscale yet approachable atmosphere, making it suitable for business travelers who want a refined lunch or couples seeking a chic dinner spot. The interior design is sleek and modern, with a welcoming warmth that appeals to locals and visitors alike.
Torno Subito – Best Trendy Italian Rooftop in Downtown Miami
- 📍 Address: 200 E Flagler St, Miami
- 💲 Price Range: $$$
- 🍝 Highlights: Inventive pastas, wagyu meatballs, creative cocktails
- 🥗 Dietary Options: Limited vegetarian options; gluten-free pasta on request
- 🏠 Ambience: Playful, lively rooftop setting
- 🎉 Best For: Birthdays, trendy nights out, and foodies
- 📅 Reservations: Strongly recommended via Resy
- 🌐 Website: tornosubitomia.com
Created by celebrity chef Massimo Bottura, Torno Subito is a one-of-a-kind Italian restaurant in Miami that mixes gourmet dining with a playful and energetic atmosphere. The rooftop location offers stunning views, while the whimsical décor and imaginative dishes create a truly memorable experience. Expect classics reimagined with bold twists, like wagyu meatballs and innovative pasta creations. With a lively energy that’s perfect for group celebrations, Torno Subito stands out as one of Miami’s most unique Italian dining spots.
Otto & Pepe – Best Casual Italian in Wynwood
- 📍 Address: 126 NW 27th St, Miami
- 💲 Price Range: $$–$$$
- 🍝 Highlights: Truffle pasta, ricotta desserts, natural Italian wines
- 🥗 Dietary Options: Vegetarian and gluten-free options available
- 🏠 Ambience: Casual, festive, and comfortable
- 👥 Best For: Groups and casual nights out
- 📅 Reservations: Walk-ins welcome; Resy available
- 🌐 Website: ottoandpepe.com
Otto & Pepe is Wynwood’s answer to a relaxed Italian dining experience. With a concise but flavorful menu, it focuses on authenticity and simplicity. The truffle pasta is a standout, while the natural wine selection makes it popular with younger crowds and food enthusiasts. The setting is casual yet vibrant, making it a perfect place for tourists who want a laid-back meal while exploring Miami’s trendy Wynwood district. It’s especially ideal for small groups or travelers looking for an affordable but memorable meal.
Dōma – Best Fine Dining Italian in Wynwood
- 📍 Address: 35 NE 26th St, Miami
- 💲 Price Range: $$$
- 🍝 Highlights: Cacio e pepe, gnocchi with porcini & prawns, black-truffle steak
- 🥗 Dietary Options: Vegetarian and gluten-free pasta available
- 🏠 Ambience: Elegant, chic, and romantic
- ❤️ Best For: Date nights and special celebrations
- 📅 Reservations: Recommended (via OpenTable)
- 🌐 Website: domawynwood.com
Dōma is a contemporary Italian restaurant in the Wynwood/Midtown area that stands out for its refined presentations and sophisticated flavor profiles. The menu balances traditional favorites with creative innovations, offering diners an elevated Italian dining experience. Standout dishes include gnocchi with porcini mushrooms and prawns, as well as a luxurious black-truffle steak. With its chic interiors and intimate lighting, Dōma is a favorite choice for couples on romantic nights out, as well as tourists looking for a stylish spot to celebrate a special occasion.
Cotoletta – Best Milanese Italian in Coconut Grove
- 📍 Address: 3206 Grand Ave, Miami
- 💲 Price Range: $$
- 🍝 Highlights: Cotoletta alla Milanese (breaded veal cutlet), prix-fixe menus
- 🥗 Dietary Options: Limited (not ideal for vegetarians or gluten-free diners)
- 🏠 Ambience: Rustic, homey, and fun
- 👨👩👧 Best For: Hearty Italian meals with friends or family
- 📅 Reservations: Recommended (small dining room)
- 🌐 Website: cotolettamiami.com
Cotoletta is dedicated to celebrating one of Northern Italy’s most famous dishes: the cotoletta alla Milanese. The prix-fixe menu offers a generous spread of antipasti, sides like spaghetti pomodoro, and the signature veal cutlet, making it a hearty and satisfying dining experience. Its rustic charm, combined with simple yet bold flavors, makes Cotoletta a hidden gem in Coconut Grove. Tourists who love authentic regional specialties and want to try something distinct from typical pasta dishes will find Cotoletta to be an excellent choice.
Stanzione 87 – Best Pizza Restaurant in Brickell
- 📍 Address: 830 SW 1st Ave, Miami
- 💲 Price Range: $
- 🍕 Highlights: Wood-fired Neapolitan pizza, Pizza Trio sampler
- 🥗 Dietary Options: Vegetarian-friendly; gluten-free crust available
- 🏠 Ambience: Very casual, counter-service
- 👨👩👧 Best For: Quick bites, families, and budget travelers
- 📅 Reservations: Not needed
- 🌐 Website: stanzione87.com
For pizza lovers, Stanzione 87 is a must-visit. Located in Brickell, this casual pizzeria is known for its authentic wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas. The Pizza Trio sampler is a popular option that lets diners taste multiple flavors in one sitting. Its counter-service style makes it convenient for tourists who want a quick, delicious meal without the formality of sit-down service. Families and budget-conscious travelers especially appreciate this spot for its affordability and authenticity.
Final Thoughts on Italian Restaurants in Miami
Miami’s Italian dining scene is as diverse as the city itself, blending luxury with casual charm. From the high-end elegance of Casa Tua, where fine dining meets romance, to the cozy familiarity of Macchialina and the creative energy of Torno Subito, visitors will find Italian cuisine for every mood and occasion. Restaurants like Felice Brickell and Dōma offer sophisticated settings and extensive wine lists, while Otto & Pepe and Stanzione 87 provide more casual, budget-friendly alternatives without sacrificing flavor. Cotoletta adds regional authenticity with its Milanese specialties, appealing to adventurous eaters. For tourists, the key takeaway is simple: no matter your budget or the occasion, Miami offers an Italian dining experience that can rival the trattorias of Rome or the bistros of Florence. Indulge in these top picks, and you’ll savor not only the flavors of Italy but also the vibrant culture and energy of Miami itself.
